The Best Mystery Games for Playstation 5 |

Update 8 May 2024: The Murder of Sherlock Holmes added at rank #29.

Here are our 10 Best Mystery Games for Playstation 5: 1

Outer Wilds (2019)

View Similar Games

Review score

Xbox One Android Nintendo Switch Playstation 5 Xbox Series X PC Windows Playstation 4

Unravel the mysteries of the universe in Outer Wilds, an award-winning open world game. Explore an ever-evolving solar system, uncover alien secrets, and enjoy a thought-provoking narrative. With no enemies to fight, you're free to discover at your own pace. Get ready for an unforgettable adventure in space!

What we like:

Unique and immersive gameplay experience
Beautiful and intricate world-building
Thought-provoking narrative
Encourages fearless discovery
Captures the mysteries of the universe

What could be improved:

May cause motion sickness
Game's physics can lead to unexpected deaths

exploration
mystery
discovery
puzzle
open-world
space
sci-fi
adventure
endless
first-person
day
story

Good match + 74 Bad match - 89

The Forgotten City (2021)

View Similar Games

Review score

Playstation 5 Xbox One PC Windows Playstation 4 Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch

Unravel the mysteries of The Forgotten City, a time-looping adventure set in an ancient Roman city. Engage with well-crafted characters, navigate ethical dilemmas, and uncover secrets that will keep you hooked. Despite its humble origins as a Skyrim mod, this game offers a captivating experience with multiple endings, making every decision count.

What we like:

Gripping story with clever twists
Immersive, detailed visuals
Strong voice performances
Thought-provoking themes and ethical dilemmas
Multiple dialogue options and quest-solving approaches

What could be improved:

Backtracking can be tedious
Limited impact of player's chosen backstory
Occasional slowdowns and glitches
Fixed map despite vast experience

mystery
narrative
adventure
rpg
story
historical
exploration
skyrim
combat
crime
thought-provoking
discovery
puzzle
first-person

Good match + 87 Bad match - 169

This Bed We Made (2023)

View Similar Games

Review score

l PC Windows Playstation 5 Playstation 4 Xbox Series X Xbox One j

This Bed We Made is a third-person mystery game in which you play as a maid in a 1950s hotel and snoop around strangers' rooms to uncover their deadly secrets. Discover what links guests together in this tale of love, heartbreak and murder!

mystery
noir
detective
cinematic
lgbtq
third-person
walking-simulator
investigation
1950s
crime
fiction
choices
historical
story
romance

Good match + 5 Bad match

The Case of the Golden Idol (2022)

View Similar Games

Review score

Screenshot of The Case of the Golden Idol

IOS iPhone Playstation 5 j Mac OS Nintendo Switch PC Windows Android Xbox Series X Xbox One

In The Case of the Golden Idol, you take on the role of a detective tasked to investigate a string of cases related to a mysterious golden idol. You must piece together evidence from the frozen tableau at each crime scene and solve puzzles in order to explain what happened.

What we like:

Innovative puzzles
Elegant execution
Trial-and-error approach and pure deduction available
Sherlockian texture that plays out in imagination
Captivating 18th century thriller

What could be improved:

Rudimentary artwork
Requires feats of deduction that may be difficult for some players

detective
mystery
conspiracy
point-and-click
crime
investigation
pixel
fiction
historical
thriller
narrative
puzzle

Good match + 17 Bad match - 21

Pentiment (2022)

View Similar Games

Review score

Xbox One Nintendo Switch j Playstation 4 Playstation 5 PC Windows Xbox Series X

Pentiment can be seen as a educational game set in the 15th century, combining point-and-click adventure with role-playing elements and a branching narrative. It follows Andreas Mahler as he tries to clear his friend's name while uncovering the secrets of a small Bavarian town.

What we like:

Captivating story
Immersive atmosphere
Beautiful visuals and sound
Interesting characters and dialogue
Deep RPG elements and replayability

What could be improved:

Limited number of puzzles which are not particularly challenging

historical
narrative
mystery
medieval
rpg
choices
book
crime
adventure
detective
education
story
fiction
stylized
local

Good match + 10 Bad match - 20

Open Roads (2024)

View Similar Games

Review score

Nintendo Switch Xbox One Android Xbox Series X Playstation 5 Playstation 4 PC Windows j Xbox Series X/s

Tess Devine and her mother, Opal, embark on a road trip adventure to explore a series of long-abandoned family properties, unearthing the past. Featuring star performances by Keri Russell (The Americans, Star Wars: Rise of Skywalker) and Kaitlyn Dever (Booksmart, Uncharted 4)

mystery
narrative
walking-simulator
interactive
story
adventure
first-person
hand-drawn
exploration
walking
discovery
investigation
fiction
cinematic
grand

Good match + 3 Bad match

The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story (2022)

View Similar Games

Review score

PC Windows Android Playstation 5 Playstation 4 Nintendo Switch IOS iPhone

Unravel the mysteries of death, and find the answers to life.A unique Mystery-Adventure Game:The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story

mystery
detective
drama
fmv
live-action
crime
choices
novelist

Good match + 8 Bad match - 3

Master Detective Archives: Rain Code (2023)

View Similar Games

Review score

Nintendo Switch Playstation 5 Xbox Series X j PC Windows

Master Detective Archives: Rain Code is a visually stunning and engaging mystery adventure game that combines Danganronpa's art style with a noir atmosphere. Solve murder mysteries in the rain-soaked city of Kanai Ward, accompanied by a mischievous ghost partner. Uncover clues, examine evidence, and unravel unexpected twists in this standout experience. A must-play for fans of the genre.

What we like:

Visually stunning
Engaging gameplay
Unexpected twists
Colorful cast of characters

What could be improved:

Some underwhelming chapters

detective
mystery
crime
detective-in-training
visual-novel
anime
narrative

Good match + 2 Bad match

Bugsnax (2020)

View Similar Games

100

Review score

Mac OS IOS iPhone Xbox Series X Xbox One Playstation 5 Playstation 4 PC Windows Nintendo Switch

Dive into the quirky world of Bugsnax! As a journalist, you'll explore the diverse Snaktooth Island, solve its mysteries, and capture 100 unique Bugsnax. With charming characters, engaging gameplay, and endless customization, you'll be captivated by this delightful adventure.

What we like:

Innovative creature-catching gameplay
Rich, immersive world with diverse biomes
Entertaining and distinct characters
Fun, fitting soundtrack
Engaging side quests and challenges

What could be improved:

puzzle
narrative
adventure
mystery
cute
muppet
horror
first-person
discovery
story
colourful
controller-support
inventive
physics
comedy

Good match + 23 Bad match - 79

Melon Journey: Bittersweet Memories (2023)

View Similar Games

Review score

Screenshot of Melon Journey: Bittersweet Memories

Xbox Series X Xbox One Nintendo Switch PC Windows Playstation 4 Playstation 5

Explore a charming, pixelated world filled to the brim with eccentric characters, criminals, and a plot as weird as it is cute. Comb every inch of Hog Town to collect clues, trail shady characters, and sneak your way through the seedy underworld. Enjoy more than 90 different electronic and jazz-inspired tracks from composer markeryjane.

narrative
mystery
story-exploration
adventure
visual-novel
cute
roller-skates
exploration
classic
hamster
chiptune
retro
casual
zombies
colourmag-header-classic

Good match + 2 Bad match

Not seeing your game? Click here to add it!

Thanks a lot for your contribution.

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7dnzGmqSeq5yeuKZ6wqikaJqVqMFus8CmnKxlkq56tcXPnmamsaOpsrPFjqmqbg%3D%3D

The Best Mystery Games for Playstation 5

Outer Wilds (2019)

The Forgotten City (2021)

This Bed We Made (2023)

The Case of the Golden Idol (2022)

Pentiment (2022)

Open Roads (2024)

The Centennial Case: A Shijima Story (2022)

Master Detective Archives: Rain Code (2023)

Bugsnax (2020)

Melon Journey: Bittersweet Memories (2023)

CATALOG

FEATURED TAGS